UPSC CDS 2017 (II)

Tribal Polity

Authentic Past Paper Standard Evaluation

Statement I: The early Aryans, who were essentially pastoral, did not develop any political structure which could measure up to a state in ancient or modern sense. Statement II: Kingship was the same as tribal chief ship; the term Rajan being used for tribal chief who was primarily a military leader and who ruled over his people and not over any specified area. Select the correct answer:

Solution & Analysis

Answer: A

Concept Political organization in the early Vedic period was kinship-based rather than territory-based, reflecting a semi-nomadic pastoral lifestyle.

Explanation NCERT highlights that the Rigvedic people identified with their tribe (Jana) rather than a fixed kingdom (Janapada). The Rajan was a 'Protector of the Tribe' (Gopa Janasya).

Logical Breakup
Logic 1: Early Aryans were pastoralists. A formal 'state' requires settled agriculture, taxation, and a standing army—features they lacked. Thus, Statement I is true.
Logic 2: The Rajan's authority was over the *people* (Vis/Jana) regardless of where they migrated. Thus, Statement II is true and explains the lack of a territorial 'state' structure.

Active Recall

Question

Why did the early Rajan not have a territorial kingdom?

Answer

Because the society was semi-nomadic and cattle-centered, meaning political power moved with the migration of the herd and the tribe.

Core Insight

The transition from 'Jana' (people) to 'Janapada' (territory) marks the most significant political shift in ancient Indian history.